Aurora Prep
← All articles

Case interviews

Should a Gym Waive Its $100 Joining Fee?

A gym wants to drop its $100 joining fee to sign up more members. Work out what one member is worth over time, then check how long the extra members stay.

An independent gym charges new members a $100 joining fee, then $60 a month. The owner wants to drop the fee. “People see that $100 at the front desk and walk out,” he tells you. “If I waive it, more of them will sign up.” In this practice case, how would you decide whether he’s right?

What is one member worth?

Start with a single member. Assume each one costs the gym $10 a month in card fees, towels, cleaning and equipment wear, so a $60 membership leaves $50. Rent, staff and the machines cost the same whether the gym signs up 40 people or 50, so leave them out of the comparison. Assume the joining fee costs almost nothing to collect, so the full $100 is profit.

Next, ask how long members stay. About one in ten cancels each month. A useful rule of thumb: divide one by the monthly cancellation rate to estimate how many months the typical member pays. Here that’s ten months, or $500. Add the fee and a new member is worth $600. In a quick case like this, you can ignore the fact that money earned next year is worth a little less than money earned today.

The gym signs up 40 new members in a typical month. That’s 40 × $600, or $24,000 from each month’s new members.

How many more members does a free sign-up need?

Without the fee, each new member is worth $500. Pause here and work out the break-even before reading on. How many sign-ups would bring in the same $24,000?

Divide $24,000 by $500 and you get 48. The gym needs eight more members a month, an increase of 20%. That sounds achievable, and many candidates stop there. But the calculation assumes the extra members stay as long as everyone else.

How long do the extra members stay?

Ask whether the gym has tried anything like this before. Suppose the owner ran a fee-free weekend last spring. The people who joined that weekend cancelled at about one in five a month, so they paid for about five months. Each one brought in five times $50, or $250.

Now work out the break-even in two parts. The 40 people who would have joined anyway each keep $100, so the gym gives up $4,000 a month in fees. Each extra member earns back $250. Divide $4,000 by $250 and you get 16 extra members, an increase of 40%. That’s twice the first estimate. Dropping the fee doesn’t just lower the price. It also attracts members who are less committed and quicker to leave.

Here’s how I’d close the case in an interview. “I’d waive the fee for one month instead of dropping it for good. I’d compare sign-ups with the same month last year, allowing for seasonal swings like the January rush, and track how quickly the new group cancels over its first three months. Breaking even takes 16 extra members who cancel at one in five a month, or fewer members who stay longer. If the trial clears that bar, I’d run it again. If not, I’d bring the fee back.”

One more question for your case partner

The trial month brings in 60 new members, compared with 40 in the same month last year. After three months, cancellations suggest the 20 extra members are leaving at about one in four a month. Is the waiver paying off? Each extra member now pays for about four months, bringing in $200. Twenty of them earn $4,000, exactly what the gym gave up in fees. The gym is no better off, and it’s busier at peak hours. Ask your partner what else the owner should check before deciding, such as whether the crowds lead any longtime members to cancel.

More from the blog

3 articles

Case interviews

Should a Theater Cut Its Matinee Price?

A theater wants to cut its matinee price from $12 to $9. Work out how many extra viewers that takes, then check where those viewers came from.

Case interviews

Where Is the Bottleneck at a Busy Car Wash?

A car wash has a line at the pay window and $72 to spend on an extra shift. Work through the bottleneck and decide where one more person would make a difference.

Case interviews

Why Can Sales Rise While Profit Falls?

A café takes in $600 more and earns $1,200 less. Work through the sales mix, then decide what the owner should do about delivery.