Aurora Prep
← All articles

Case interviews

Why Can Sales Rise While Profit Falls?

A café takes in $600 more and earns $1,200 less. Work through the sales mix, then decide what the owner should do about delivery.

The owner of a neighborhood café has a puzzle for you: “We took in $600 more last week and made $1,200 less. Should I turn off the delivery app?” In this practice case, those two figures are all you have at the start. What would you ask to see first?

Ask what changed in the order book

Start with the tickets from both weeks. How many orders came across the counter, how many came through the app, and what did the café earn on each? That breakdown lets you separate three explanations that look alike in the weekly totals: customers bought a different mix, the café charged different prices, or an order became more expensive to fill.

Suppose the café filled 1,000 orders each week. A counter order brought in $10 and cost $4 to fill. A delivery order brought in $12 and cost $10 to fill, including food, packaging and the app fee. Those amounts stayed the same in both weeks. What changed was where the orders came from: delivery went from 200 tickets to 500.

Follow one order before adding up a thousand

A counter order leaves $6 after variable costs; a delivery order leaves $2. Accountants call that amount the contribution margin per order. It is the money available to cover fixed costs, such as rent. Once those are covered, the rest is operating profit.

In the first week, 800 counter orders contributed $4,800 and 200 delivery orders contributed $400, for a total of $5,200. In the second, 500 of each contributed $3,000 and $1,000, respectively. With fixed costs of $3,000 each week, operating profit fell from $2,200 to $1,000.

Here is the calculation you can say aloud in the interview: the café sold 300 more $12 orders and 300 fewer $10 orders. That explains the extra $600 in sales. Each change in the mix also exchanged $6 of contribution for $2. Multiply the $4 difference by 300 and the entire $1,200 profit decline is accounted for.

Should the owner switch off delivery?

The arithmetic explains the profit decline. It cannot tell you what those delivery customers would have done without the app. Picture two tickets coming into the kitchen. One arrives at 3 p.m. when the cook is idle, from someone who would otherwise eat at home. Filling it adds $2. The other takes the last lunch slot, and a customer who would have ordered at the counter walks away. Filling that ticket costs the café $4 compared with serving the walk-in.

A recommendation the owner can act on: keep delivery open during quiet hours. For two weeks, cap app orders during selected busy lunches and compare them with similar lunches when the app stays open. Record counter orders, delivery orders and total contribution for each lunch. If the cap improves contribution, keep it during the rush. If counter sales barely move, lifting the cap lets the café earn those $2 orders again.

A follow-up to try with a case partner

Suppose the owner can pause just three delivery orders during tomorrow’s lunch. How many extra counter orders would make the pause worthwhile? The three deliveries would have contributed $6. One extra counter order earns exactly that back; two leave the café $6 ahead. That gives the owner something specific to watch at the till, and gives your interviewer a clear reason for your recommendation.

More from the blog

3 articles

Case interviews

Mastering the Art of Case Prep

How to adapt a framework, work through unfamiliar numbers, and turn a business case into a decision.