Case interviews
Should a Theater Cut Its Matinee Price?
A theater wants to cut its matinee price from $12 to $9. Work out how many extra viewers that takes, then check where those viewers came from.

A neighborhood movie theater sells weekday matinee tickets for $12. The owner wants to cut the price to $9. “Our afternoon screen is two-thirds empty,” she tells you. “Wouldn’t a cheaper ticket fill it?” In this practice case, what would you need to know before agreeing?
What does one matinee viewer earn the theater?
Start with a single ticket. Assume the theater pays a flat $2 per ticket in booking and card fees at either price, so it keeps $10 of each $12 ticket. The average viewer also buys snacks that leave $4 after their cost. So one matinee viewer adds $14. Rent, staff and the projector cost the same whether the seats are full or empty, so leave them out of the comparison.
A typical weekday matinee sells 200 of the screen’s 300 seats. That’s 200 viewers at $14, or $2,800 per screening.
How many more viewers does a $9 ticket need?
At $9, each viewer adds $9 minus $2 in fees plus $4 from snacks, or $11. Pause here and work out the break-even before reading on. How many viewers would keep the screening at $2,800?
Divide $2,800 by $11 and you get just under 255. The theater needs about 55 more viewers, an increase of more than a quarter, just to stand still. That fits in the 100 empty seats, so capacity isn’t the problem. The question is whether a $3 discount brings in that many people.
Who are the extra viewers?
Not every new matinee viewer is new to the theater. Evening tickets cost $16, so an evening viewer adds $16 minus $2 plus $4, or $18. Someone who would have come at 7 p.m. and switches to the cheaper 2 p.m. show adds $11 instead. The theater loses $7 every time that happens, even though the afternoon room looks fuller.
Here’s how I’d close the case in an interview. “I’d test the $9 price on two weekdays for a month and keep the other weekdays at $12 for comparison. I’d track matinee attendance, snack sales and evening attendance on the same days. If the day’s total contribution, matinee plus evening, rises compared with the $12 days, I’d roll out the lower price.”
One more question for your case partner
On the test days, the matinee sells 270 tickets. But evening attendance falls by 20, and the box office thinks those viewers moved to the afternoon. Is the $9 price working? The matinee now earns 270 × $11, or $2,970, which is $170 more than before. The 20 lost evening viewers took $18 each, or $360, with them. The theater is $190 a day worse off. Ask your partner what evidence would show whether those 20 viewers really switched shows.


