Aurora Prep
← All articles

Case interviews

Where Is the Bottleneck at a Busy Car Wash?

A car wash has a line at the pay window and $72 to spend on an extra shift. Work through the bottleneck and decide where one more person would make a difference.

It’s noon on Saturday. From the street, the owner of an express car wash can see a line at the pay window. While she watches, two drivers slow down, take one look at the line, and keep going. “I’ve got someone who can work the lunch rush,” she tells you. “Should I open the second pay window?”

Before you answer, walk one car through the wash. It pays, pulls into a bay where an attendant scrubs the wheels, then joins the conveyor. From inside the building you can see something the owner missed from the street. The cashier keeps finishing a sale and waiting for space to open up ahead.

How many cars can each station handle?

In this practice case, one cashier can take a payment every 60 seconds. The wheel scrub takes one attendant 90 seconds per car. The conveyor can take a new car every 75 seconds, even though each car spends several minutes in the tunnel. Every car goes through all three steps.

Put the rates in the same units. The cashier can handle 60 cars an hour. At the wheel bay, 3,600 seconds per hour divided by 90 seconds per car gives you 40 cars an hour. The conveyor can take 48. With cars arriving steadily and each station running at those rates, the site can wash 40 cars an hour. Opening the second window still leaves one person scrubbing 40 sets of wheels.

Where would you put the extra person?

There’s an empty wheel bay beside the first. A second attendant could work on another car at the same time, bringing wheel prep up to 80 cars an hour. Pause here and give the owner your estimate. How many more cars could she wash in a three-hour rush?

The conveyor now sets the pace at 48 an hour. With enough drivers waiting, the second attendant adds eight washes an hour, or 24 over the shift. The owner can use that figure to decide what the extra pair of hands is worth.

Would you pay for the shift?

Suppose the attendant costs $72 for the shift and each additional wash leaves $6 after water, soap, and other per-wash costs. Twelve extra washes cover the shift. If all 24 are additional sales, the owner comes out $72 ahead. But some drivers in that Saturday line might already be planning to come back after lunch. Moving their washes earlier helps the queue and leaves daily sales exactly where they were.

Here’s how I’d close the case in an interview. “I’d try the second wheel bay for a Saturday lunch. I’d count the drivers who turn away and compare full-day wash totals with similar Saturdays, accounting for weather and promotions. If we consistently gain at least 13 paid washes for the day, I’d schedule the shift regularly.”

One more question for your case partner

On a trial Saturday the site washes 18 more cars during lunch and 10 fewer afterward. Morning volume is the same. Would you book the attendant again on those numbers? The net gain is eight washes. They earn $48 toward a $72 shift, leaving the owner $24 short. Ask your partner what a shorter wait would have to be worth to justify that gap.

More from the blog

3 articles

Case interviews

Why Can Sales Rise While Profit Falls?

A café takes in $600 more and earns $1,200 less. Work through the sales mix, then decide what the owner should do about delivery.

Case interviews

Mastering the Art of Case Prep

How to adapt a framework, work through unfamiliar numbers, and turn a business case into a decision.