Career decisions
Is consulting still a 'smart' option?
A May 2024 perspective on hiring delays, how firms build their talent pipelines, and what candidates could do during that recruiting cycle.

The consulting industry has long been a popular choice for MBA graduates, offering prestigious positions, competitive salaries, and exciting career prospects. However, recent developments have seen many top consulting firms delaying the hiring of new consultants from MBA programs. If you are in-the-know on recent economic events, this likely is not a surprise to you. But, for those of you that are not reading the Wall Street Journal daily (you should start), we'll give an overview on why firms are having these pauses.
What's going on in the industry?
Several factors have contributed to the decision by consulting firms to postpone onboarding new MBA hires; however, most are related to the economic uncertainty that lies ahead - not only in the USA, but globally.
1. Economic Uncertainty: The global economic landscape has been volatile recently, with concerns about recession, inflation, and geopolitical tensions. While talks of recessions have been prevalent since 2015, we have not had a "true" recession in the sense. Since the Great Financial Crisis in 2008, the S&P 500 is up 517% as of today, and the NASDAQ is up a staggering 994% (that's a whopping 64% annualized).
For nearly the past decade, analysts all over Wall Street have been claiming all the reasons why a recession is needed and they've all claimed it will be in the next year or two. Ten years later, the only blip the market has really seen was the 30%+ technical recession from Covid. However, as you know, markets saw a pretty strong and faster "V-shaped" recovery from the pandemic pullback.
Over the last year, the Federal Reserve has been struggling to combat inflationary pressures by raising interest rates to stall spending from businesses and consumers alike. The looming question has been whether Fed will be successful in providing a "soft-landing" as economists and investors refer to the ability to raise interest rates without throwing the economy into a deep recession. This ongoing uncertainty has led many firms to adopt a cautious approach to hiring, as they assess the potential impact on their business.
2. Shifting Client Demands: The nature of consulting work is evolving, with clients increasingly seeking specialized expertise and digital solutions. Firms are taking time to reevaluate their talent needs and ensure they have the right mix of skills to meet changing client demands. As you have seen in our other articles and broadly across the consulting industry, businesses are demanding more advice on how to position their firms to successfully use AI to unlock efficiency and drive competitive advantages. While most firms have focused on being strong in strategy, they are now seeing the need to bulk up on their technical specialists to meet this demand.
3. Cost-Cutting Measures: In response to the economic challenges, some consulting firms are implementing cost-cutting measures, which can include reducing or delaying new hires to manage expenses. For most firms that you see in headlines, the common plan is to now offer acceptance letters to MBA graduates with tentative start dates a year later. The WSJ highlighted earlier this year that some firms are even offering MBA graduates stipends of $20,000 to $40,000 to learn a new language, work for non-profits, or even become yoga instructors licensed as interim options while they wait to start later.
How Will This Strategy Impact Consulting Firms in the Long Term?
While delaying hiring may provide short-term financial relief, we believe it could have long-term consequences for consulting firms and the industry as a whole:
1. Talent Pipeline Disruption: Consistently delaying or reducing MBA hires may disrupt the talent pipeline, making it harder for firms to attract and retain top candidates in the future. As more and more firms continue to delay start dates, and graduates have hundreds of thousands of dollars in debt to begin paying on, we imagine a significant percentage of strong applicants will look to other industries like technology or finance to start their careers.
2. Skills Gap: As client needs evolve, firms that fail to bring in fresh talent with relevant skills may struggle to remain competitive and meet changing demands. Additionally, with significant amounts of new consultants working virtually and sitting stagnantly "on the bench" as we call it (those consultants not staffed on a project), there are many consultants that aren't gaining the proper skillsets they would in a normal environment. The longer consulting firms continue to struggle with staffing consultants, the larger the risk of a growing talent pool that will be unprepared for when business picks up due to a lack of knowledge and training.
3. Reputation Impact: Firms known for consistently delaying or rescinding offers may face reputational damage, affecting their ability to attract the best and brightest MBA graduates in the long run. In short, the longer top-tier firms continue to delay hiring, they will become less attractive for top applicants. Right now, consulting is going through one of these waves of low demand, but those firms that are able to position and balance building new talent and retention will succeed in the end.
How does this impact you: The aspiring management consultant?
For MBA and undergrad students aspiring to enter the consulting industry, these hiring delays can be unsettling. However, there are several steps you can take to navigate this challenging landscape:
1. Broaden Your Horizons: While consulting remains a popular choice, you should explore opportunities in other industries that align with their skills and interests. Technology, healthcare, and financial services are among the sectors that continue to hire MBA graduates and strong undergraduates. While consulting may be your number one choice, it doesn't hurt to have a backup plan. Having industry experience may actually help you be a better consultant in the long-haul if you make a pivot a few years later on in your career.
2. Develop Relevant Skills: Focus on developing skills that are in high demand, such as data analytics, digital transformation, artificial intelligence, machine learning, and GenAI. These skills can make you a more attractive candidate across various industries. Tech is becoming evermore mainstream today, so it's essential to have an understanding of it across the board. You do not have to be a coder, but having a baseline understanding of how firms can leverage this technology will be essential to anyone entering consulting going forward. Strategy alone is no longer the answer.
3. Network and Stay Informed: Engage with alumni, industry professionals, and career services to stay informed about hiring trends and opportunities. Building a strong network can open doors to potential job leads. You have heard the old adage that success is when preparation meets luck, and this is absolutely true. Treat your journey into consulting like running your own business: consider the marketing, branding, sales approach, and selling points needed to get you in the door with the right individuals. In our 1-on-1 consultations, we have helped dozens of individuals learn how to setup the right networking approach 9-12 months in advance so that their pipeline delivers at the right time.
4. Be Flexible and Persistent: Recognize that the hiring process may take longer than usual. Be open to different roles and locations, and continue to refine your application materials to showcase your unique value proposition. This may mean looking at boutique or mid-sized consulting firms. Luckily, all firms will train you with the proper toolkit to become a management consulting whether you are at MBB or a smaller firm. In the end, it depends on the goal you have for yourself.
While the current hiring delays may seem discouraging, in our view, we see these resolving over the next year or two. Consulting regularly undergoes impacts from business cycles, and this time is no different. If your goal is to become a management consultant, stick to it. Sometimes entering the industry immediately after graduating is not always how folks enter. It is likely the easiest if you are a student at a target school, but in today's age we are seeing more and more individuals enter from non-traditional paths, such as from technology or finance. With that being said, keep your head up high, make your plan, and start case prepping today. Success = When Luck and Preparation Meet.
Cheers!
Your team at Aurora Prep 🚀
Originally published by The Aurora Co. Read on LinkedIn ↗


